Site Logo

MicroStrategy ($MSTR): Down 68% Amid Bitcoin's 33% Dip

Speculation Rises Over MSTR’s Potential Index Removal
Speculation Rises Over MSTR’s Potential Index Removal

$MSTR has experienced a sharp 68% decline, far outpacing Bitcoin's ($BTC) 33% drop, raising alarms in the market.

Speculation is rife about potential removal from Nasdaq 100 index and MSCI USA indices, which could spark an estimated $2.8B in outflows from MSCI alone.

With ~$9B of its market cap tied to passive investments like ETFs, this could amplify volatility.

Yet, even post-decline, $MSTR trades at a 1.00x multiple to modified net asset value (mNAV)

Recall the 2022 bear market: It traded below mNAV, creating a discount to its Bitcoin holdings.

Market Watch: Speculation Rises Over MSTR’s Potential Index Removal

Speculation is heating up around MicroStrategy (MSTR) as investors brace for the possibility that the stock could be removed from the Nasdaq-100 and MSCI USA indices.

If the delisting from the MSCI USA index materializes, analysts estimate that the move alone could trigger around $2.8 billion in passive outflows, mainly from funds that mirror MSCI benchmarks.

And that’s only part of the ripple effect.

Roughly $9 billion of MSTR’s total market cap is currently tied up in passive strategies such as ETFs and index-linked products. Any forced rebalancing by these funds could introduce sharp, short-term volatility—a familiar pattern for stocks heavily owned by passive vehicles.

Yet here’s the interesting twist:

Even after the recent pullback, MSTR is still trading almost exactly at 1.00× its modified net asset value (mNAV). In simple terms, the market is pricing the company nearly equal to the value of its Bitcoin holdings and adjusted assets.

We’ve seen this story before

During the 2022 crypto bear market, MicroStrategy actually traded below its mNAV—creating a rare discount where the stock was valued less than its underlying Bitcoin holdings. That discount eventually corrected as sentiment improved.

Today’s setup is different, but the themes rhyme:

High passive ownership, big index implications, and a price tightly hugging mNAV. Traders now wait to see whether the index committees confirm any changes—and how the market reacts if billions in passive flows suddenly turn into selling pressure.

For now, MSTR sits in a fragile balance between fundamentals, Bitcoin sentiment, and mechanical flows that could swing its price sharply in the weeks ahead.

Analysis: Why MSTR Crashed Harder Than Bitcoin

The drastic underperformance of MSTR compared to Bitcoin itself reveals the double-edged sword of the company's strategy. While the leveraged approach amplified gains during Bitcoin's bull run, it's now magnifying losses. Investors aren't just pricing in the drop in Bitcoin's value; they're pricing in increased risk—the risk of margin calls, the company's ability to service its debt, and the potential for a vicious cycle if forced selling occurs. This creates a 'beta' effect, where MSTR becomes a more volatile, high-risk proxy for Bitcoin itself.

Why MSTR is Getting Hammered Harder Than Bitcoin

The drastic underperformance of MSTR compared to Bitcoin itself reveals the double-edged sword of the company's high-conviction strategy. Investors aren't just reacting to the drop in Bitcoin's value; they are pricing in amplified risk. MicroStrategy isn't just a company that holds Bitcoin—it has fundamentally bet its entire corporate strategy on it, taking on substantial debt to make its purchases. This "leverage" supercharged its gains on the way up but is now magnifying losses and sparking fears about the company's financial health if the downturn continues. This creates a 'beta' effect, where MSTR stock acts as a more volatile, high-risk proxy for Bitcoin itself.

The Bigger Picture: A Warning for Corporate Bitcoin Adoption?

This event serves as a crucial case study for other companies considering adding Bitcoin to their treasury. MicroStrategy's extreme volatility highlights the significant accounting and shareholder value risks involved. While other companies like Tesla have dabbled in Bitcoin, none have gone 'all-in' to the same degree. The MSTR sell-off may cause other CFOs to reconsider, sticking to more traditional treasury assets or waiting for the establishment of Bitcoin ETFs as a less risky alternative for corporate exposure.

What to Watch Next

For investors and observers, the key metrics to watch now are:

  • Bitcoin's price stability around the $40,000 level

  • Any statements from MicroStrategy regarding their debt obligations or hedging strategies

  • Trading volume in MSTR to see if the sell-off is accelerating or finding a bottom
    The coming weeks will test whether Michael Saylor's conviction can withstand one of the most significant challenges to his corporate strategy to date.

MicroStrategy's journey from a traditional software company to a Bitcoin-focused treasury was once hailed as revolutionary. However, today's historic crash is its most severe test yet. The coming days will be critical. The market will be watching to see if Bitcoin finds a floor and, more importantly, whether Michael Saylor's unwavering conviction can calm investor nerves and stabilize the company's stock. For now, MicroStrategy remains the ultimate example of the immense potential—and profound risk—of tying a corporate destiny directly to the volatile crypto market.
NextGen Digital... Welcome to WhatsApp chat
Howdy! How can we help you today?
Type here...